Was already stated, but main reasons this was brought up are:
- Redundant tagging separation, as we already have
ai composition,ai generated, andai assistedto separate “artistic effort” - The way the site handles user links means people that do multiple types of content sort of get shafted; if someone sees
prompter:blahand clicks for more, they won’t see all theirartist:blahoreditor:blah. Yes, site profile lists those… but that assumes there is a profile, and that the user knows to click on it to check… not great - Automatic tagging from uploading currently defaults to
prompter:blah, something uploaders might not change when appropriate
Basically we don’t want to lose the whole “separating pure prompted work from heavily guided and edited work” functionality, but the current way of doing it through both the type and origin tag seems clunky and overall detrimental.
As for the name of the tag itself, that’s far from settled.
creator:blah felt neutral, director:blah is what’s used in e6ai so maybe people are used to that. author:blah could definitely work. There’s also producer:blah, or simply just by:blah.